Jay Jordan Hawke
Find me on Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube!
  • Jay Jordan Hawke
  • Jay Hawke's Blog
  • Interviews
  • About the Author
  • Edgy Links
  • Contact Jay Jordan Hawke
  • Book Reviews
  • My Writings on the Interwebs

Faux News Contributor Opposes Helping Gay Teens

12/28/2010

1 Comment

 
On December 13, California state Senator Mark Leno introduced the "Fair, Accurate, Inclusive, and Respectful Education Act" (FAIR) to add the contributions of gay people to the history curriculum in California, hoping that such visibility will serve to reduce gay teen bullying and gay teen suicide. 

Not surprisingly, Faux News disagrees with the bill.  On December 17, Fox and Friends interviewed Fox contributor, Tucker Carlson, who is evidently an expert on gay teen suicide.

Tucker had some very unusual objections to the bill.

He says:

"There are two problems with this.[FAIR] One, it's propaganda and two, it's blackmail. The point of history is to teach what happened. Not what you wanted to happen. Not what you hope will happen but what actually happened."

This is in fact not true  The bill doesn't suggest that lies about the contributions of gay people be published, only that the truth about their contributions be included in the history curriculum.  The fact that the March on Washington was organized by a gay man,  Bayard Rustin, for example, is a fact, not propaganda.  Propaganda would be writing that Bayard Rustin, a gay man, organized the March on Washington, and hence gay people are superior to straight people, because, after all, no straight person ever thought of a march for civil rights.  See the difference, Tucker?  Well, maybe you don't, but smart people do.

Not getting his stupidity quota in for a 2 minute interview, Tucker continued:

"In this case, a lawmaker is saying, portray a special -- an interest group in a positive light or kids will be hurt. Hence the blackmail. They are basically saying if you don't do this, kids could die. And that's an outrageous thing to say."

This is incorrect.  No one is saying "do this, or gay kids will die."  What people are saying is that gay teens ARE dieing, so lets do this!  That's a fundamental difference.

Then Tucker launched into his philosophy of history, something he obviously spent a lot of time developing:

"What I -- what they're saying is the point of history is to raise the self-esteem of students. It's to find yourself in the history book and see the group to which you belong portrayed in a positive light. And again, of course, that's not the point of history. The point of history is to teach you what happened....It's the -- that's exactly right. It's not to make people feel good about themselves. It's not to achieve social aims. It's to tell the truth about what went before. And that's being subverted by a lawmaker and it's dangerous."

Subverted???  Wow, subversives in the California Senate?  We better resurrect Joseph McCarthy!  Wait, we don't need McCarthy.  We have Tucker! 

But what Tucker fails to mention is that FAIR simply adds the contributions of gay people to an already existing list of minority contributions.  For some reason, Tucker didn't advocate eliminating the contributions of other minority groups from the history curriculum. He only advocated keeping gays from being added to it.  If history is not about teaching contributions, then why are the contributions of other minorities ok to keep in?  But gay contributions are not? 

I'm actually not necessarily disagreeing with Tucker's philosophy of history.  He is right that the point of history is to teach what happened.  But what happened is that gay people have been oppressed, persecuted, harassed, tortured, excluded, and murdered for thousands of years by straight people.  It is also a fact that some very brave people have tried to end heterosexual bigotry.  And those facts are not in the history books.  If it's the point of history to learn what happened, lets put the facts in the history books.  And to suggest that putting in facts is somehow inconsistent with making gay teens feel better about themselves is factually incorrect.  Including the fact that Bernard Rustin was gay makes gay people feel better.  So, the truth has been told, and gay teens feel better.  Who could possibly object to that?

Tucker continues by stating that it won't work, because his extensive knowledge of the studies done on this subject reveal that telling the truth about gay contributions to history won't help them at all.

"Well, I mean, not only is it -- first of all, it's unproven. There isn't social science that demonstrates that teaching children about the glories of the gay rights movement will reduce bullying. That just doesn't -- we don't know that."

Actually according to The California Safe Schools Coalition, as pointed out in Media Matters, surveys of California students and school administrators on 3 different years revealed:

"Students who report learning about LGBT issues in school... report fewer mean rumors or lies spread about them, fewer reports of being made fun of because of their looks or the way they talk, and less LGBT bullying at school."  The California Safe Schools Coalition also concluded that not only did more LGBT students feel safer at schools with LGBT issues in the curriculum, but "[m]ore straight students report feeling safe if they learned about LGBT issues."

So, if by "There isn't social science that demonstrates that teaching children about the glories of the gay rights movement will reduce bullying," he actually means, "There IS," then finally Tucker has said something factually accurate.  There is a first time for everything.
1 Comment
michael_blackheart
1/2/2011 05:02:01 am

Tucker Carlson is a mean spirited imbecile. Anything he says should be
instantly and immediately discredited and ignored.

mb

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Jay Jordan Hawke is the host of On the Edge and author of the awarding winning Two-Spirit Chronicles, which includes: Pukawiss the Outcast, A Scout is Brave, and Onwaachige the Dreamer.

    Archives

    February 2021
    December 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    March 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    June 2012
    March 2012
    January 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010

    Categories

    All
    Anti Gay Bullying
    A Scout Is Brave
    Book Reviews
    Boy Scouts
    Bullying
    Christianity
    Coming Out
    Dadt
    Doma
    Entertainment
    Faux News
    Gay Heroes
    Gay Marriage
    Gay Rights
    Gay Teens
    Gay Teen Suicide
    Hate Crimes
    Homophobia
    Just Kidding
    Lawrence King
    Matthew Shepard
    Michelle Bachmann
    Pop Culture
    Prayers For Bobby
    Pukawiss: The Outcast
    Pukawiss: The Outcast
    Quotes
    Religious Right
    Republicans
    Right Wing Loons
    Sarah Palin
    Seth Walsh
    Snyder V. Phelps
    Suicide
    The First Amendment
    Thoughts From Jay Hawke

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.